Early photos show that Hickory Cluster once included a large children's playground between Blocks 2 and 3 near the western property boundary.
Although not specifically shown on the original site plan drawings, this playground appears to be thoughtfully designed and most likely the work of Architect Charles M. Goodman or an associate.
Unfortunately the playground site was in a flood plain. So the playground equipment eventually deteriorated, became a greater liability, and was removed. Only the original wooden and metal bench remained.
Later two Goodman-style post-and-extended-beam swingsets were designed and installed, one near the playground and one near Block 1. Since then, violent storms have wreaked havoc with Hickory Cluster trees. A tree felled by the June 29, 2012 derecho storm crushed the swingset near the original playground. The Board of Directors replaced both HCA swingsets in 2012 and added surrounding ground safety material.
In addition, one large tree partly-downed during the same derecho storm threatened to fall on a nearby RA footpath. During the difficult and dangerous removal process, that tree was pulled clear of other supporting trees farther away than expected and accidentally damaged the former playground bench.
The HCA Board of Directors agreed soon thereafter to replace the bench, but a Director felt strongly that a location to the side of the now-open meadow might allow children and adults to run and play more freely. It would eliminate a potential obstacle, potential injuries, and potential HCA liability. It would be easier for grounds crews to maintain the meadow grass. And since the original playground was long gone, the original bench location was no longer relevant.
Several Members disagreed with the Board and argued for replacement of the bench back in its original location in the middle of the meadow so they could be closer to their children.
UPDATE: During the July 17, 2013 HCA Board of Directors meeting, Members and Directors discussed and then approved purchase and installation of two new wooden-slat benches similar to the original design, one in the Block 3 meadow as originally sited, and one nearby. HCA Vice President Ralph Youngren FAIA is leading the effort.
