Showing posts with label reston. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reston. Show all posts

Saturday, June 17, 2023

HCA REVISED GOV DOCS v4 ... DANGEROUS = AGAIN: NO

On one hand, the Board heard, again, and finally and commendably incorporated several suggestions from Members at the May 2023 Annual Meeting to be voted upon by HCA Members on or before a scheduled June 21 Special Meeting.

On the other hand, the Board apparently is using incomplete information to justify unlimited new powers to more easily make significant decisions that could dangerously impact Member rights and property.  And they continue to pursue an all-or-nothing approach rather than voting on individual issues.

Here are links to the current v4 documents with yellow-highlighted areas denoting, but not limited to, the following remaining unresolved issues:

PROPOSED REVISED ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION v4

1.  Unlimited fines for rules violations, page 5, Article III 3. c. ... VERY DANGEROUS:  "The Board of Directors may ... impose monetary charges when there exists a violation of any of the provisions of the Governing Documents or the Rules and Regulations." This could be financially devastating to retired homeowners on limited incomes.

2.  Unlimited power to establish charges for Common Area use, page 5, Article III 3. d. ... Members could be charged for parking and other uses.

3.  Unlimited "preferential" allocation by Board of Common Area use, page 5, Article III 3. d. ... What is the real intent of the new weasel word "preferential" vs. the previous weasel word "unequal"  And "preferential" implies that some Members may be more equal than others.

4.   Unlimited rules changes by Board, page 5, Article III 3. d. ... VERY DANGEROUS:  "Rules and Regulations may be amended or repealed by the Board of Directors at any time."  This new text gives the Board overwhelming and possibly abusive authority to change any rule at any time, with no notice or Member feedback.  Currently, General Resolutions rules and regulations changes can only be made after sufficient notice to and feedback from Members within a clearly defined process, including an announced public Member hearing, described in HCA Special Resolution 2:  Creation, Modification, and Deletion of Rules.

5.  Six-month time limit for catastrophic damage repair, page 6, Article IV 4. ... DANGEROUS:  This is an impossible deadline, considering major externally-controlled legal, administrative, contractor, and supply issues impacting catastrophe recovery.  A recent lengthy Block 2 rowhouse recovery project is but one example.  This limit also makes quickness a higher priority than quality work, full scope, or prohibitive expense.

6.  Non-owner household members can be HCA Directors, page 6, Article VI ... VERY DANGEROUS:  "The Board of Directors shall be composed of seven (7) persons, all of whom shall be Members of the Association or members of the Member's household ... ."  ONLY vested homeowners-of-record should govern OTHER homeowners of record.  NON-homeowner adult children, spouses, or tenants should NOT have that power.  The Board attorney's larger-candidate-pool-is-better argument is a deceptive half-truth.  HCA has virtually ALWAYS had seven Directors in place as outcomes of annual meetings.  And actual HCA practice is that of surprise "ambush" nominations and other pre-planned and pre-supported actions AT, not before, annual meetings themselves, to strategically limit competition or opposition.  Rarely do candidates announce their intentions BEFORE the meetings, and if they do they risk petty opposition.  Example:  At the 2023 annual meeting, an end-term Director publicly withheld their real intention to seek re-election until AT the annual meeting itself, not before, effectively thwarting other candidates.  So in reality, there were FIVE candidates for THREE vacancies, not just ONE candidate as the Board cover letter FAQs and document footnotes deceivingly stated.

PROPOSED REVISED BYLAWS v4

1.  Unlimited power to establish charges for Common Area use, page 2, Article I 2. l. ... See Articles same issue above

2.  Unlimited "preferential" allocation by Board of Common Area use, page 2, Article I 2. l. ... See Articles same issue above

3.  Unlimited rules changes by Board, page 2, Article I 2. l. ... VERY DANGEROUS:  See Articles same issue above

4.  Unlimited proxy form manipulation by Board, page 5, Article III 7. (b) ...  DANGEROUS:  The current Board has manipulated the last few elections one way or another, as outlined in earlier posts on this website.  This gives the Board additional options for manipulating proxy forms to eliminate non-Director proxies and other devices to promote a Board-preferred slate of candidates. One example:  requiring all candidates to nominate BEFORE the annual meeting, and then extending the nomination period to other preferred candidates AFTER they know who pre-nominated.  It will most likely be anti-competitive and unfair to candidates who do not agree with the status quo.

5.  Unlimited Common Area modification by Board, page 6, Article IV 2. (b) ... VERY DANGEROUS:  Current Bylaws require a 2/3 affected neighbor approval of Common Area changes, except for emergency or preventive repairs.  But even that has not stopped recent past Boards from planting big trees that will grow into homes or block their windows.  Removing the current restriction will make the situation even worse because there will be NO restrictions on what the Board can do immediately adjacent to your Goodman House without your knowledge or input.

6.  Non-owner household members can be HCA Directors, page 6, Article IV 3. (a) ... VERY DANGEROUS:  See Articles same issue above

7.  Unlimited Director candidate manipulation by Board, page 6, Article IV 3. (a) ...  DANGEROUS:  The current Board has manipulated the last few elections one way or another, as outlined in earlier posts on this website.  This gives the Board additional options for now-officially recruiting and promoting their own Board-preferred slate of candidates.  It will most likely be anti-competitive and unfair to candidates who do not agree with the status quo.

8.  Unlimited amount of Lot repair charges to Members by Board, page 11, Article VIII 1. (a) ... VERY DANGEROUS:  "Charges incurred by the Association in performing exterior maintenance on the Lot as permitted by the Reston Deed will be considered an assessment and collectible as such."  This is new to the HCA Bylaws and could possibly be financially devastating to retired homeowners on limited incomes, even if actually allowed by the Reston Deed.

RECOMMENDATION:  Until these proposed dangerous revisions are resolved, continue to vote AGAINST the proposed revised documents.

Monday, February 28, 2022

RA COVENANTS ADVISOR TO HCA DEPARTS @ FRI MAR 4

Updated May 16, 2022

RA and HCA will lose the substantial knowledge and experience of RA Covenants Advisor Vern James when he leaves to take on new and greater responsibilities nearer his home as the Ashburn Village Community Association, Inc. Resident Services Manager, effective Friday, March 4.  Unknown to most of us during his RA tenure, Vern was also an accomplished writer with nine novels and more than 50 short stories published over a period of 26 years.  

RA is currently in the process of seeking a replacement.  Until that person is on board and trained, the temporary Covenants Advisor for Hickory Cluster is Catherine Castrence, nicknamed "Cat", ccastrence@reston.org.

Vern joined RA in September 2013 and simultaneously supported up to 30 Reston clusters, including Hickory Cluster, for almost nine years.  He became an expert in RA Covenants, Codes, and Restrictions, RA Maintenance & Use Standards, RA DRB Design Guidelines, and HCA Cluster Standards.  He tirelessly helped HCA Members maintain and improve their Goodman Houses, the majority of whom value compliance with protective rules that enhance daily quality of life, Goodman architectural integrity, and resulting property value growth.  And he did this in a friendly manner, even in the face of a heavy workload and unfortunate opposition from a small number of residents who believe RA protective rules, to which they agreed when they purchased their Reston homes, do not apply to them.  Vern was an effective professional, a friend of Hickory Cluster, and a valuable Reston asset.  He will be missed.

Friday, February 4, 2022

BLOCK 2 GOODMAN HOUSE PRICE RECORD @ FEB 3

Updated February 25, 2022

The Payton Residence, an almost fully renovated Hickory Cluster Block 2 Model A2B Goodman House with a near-perfect rear southern exposure to central HCA Common Area, sold for a record $745,200 price yesterday following the July 2021 departure of a beloved long-time medical professional homeowner and her late husband, a highly-regarded journalist, bureau chief, and executive editor.  They met as college students, married, and lived together in Belgium, Israel, Italy, France, and most recently Reston.  Both were serious modern architecture, rock music, foreign film, and Porsche 911 fans.  

A realtor who rarely resells Hickory Cluster Goodman Houses initially sold the home as an off-MLS private sale to an investor buyer in September 2021 for $480,000.  After homeowner out-of-state relatives managing her affairs decided the home was a deferred maintenance "money pit," and to cash out the estate asset as quickly as possible, the realtor they chose did so by representing BOTH the homeowner seller AND investor buyer as what is termed a "dual agent." But as a prominent Hickory Cluster realtor expert diplomatically understated, the dual agent realtor did the homeowner seller a "disservice" by not allowing typical full and open price competition.  Even the realtor's own brockerage company advises that, according to a recent MLS study validated by two Ph.D. economists, "The median sales price for homes sold on-MLS was 16.98% higher than homes sold off-MLS."  In other words, the homeowner seller and her estate lost an estimated $81,504 through an off-MLS sale with no competition among an otherwise huge market of highly-motivated buyers who also could have renovated the home and lived in it.  

But wait, there's more:  As part of the initial deal, the very same realtor arranged to represent the investor as seller during the on-MLS, three-day, six-offer, $745,200 second transaction in February 2022.  She ostensibly earned both a 6% September 2021 commission (homeowner seller 3.5% + investor buyer 2.5%), but also the 3.5% February 2022 investor seller commission.  So who benefited most from this apparent conflict of interest?  With full on-MLS price competition for their follow-on resale, the realtor and investor got the real deals.  The homeowner, with no MLS price competition for the initial resale, did not.

Increased resale prices also mean increased annual assessed property values and property taxes for everyone else.  For one nearby Block 2 Model A2B Goodman House, the 2022 Notice of Real Estate Assessment Change dated February 22, 2022 reports an increase of 15.11% from 2021, no doubt in part due to this February 3 resale.  Corresponding property tax amounts tentatively increased $878.88 from $5,815.44 to $6,694.32, subject to final county tax rate decisions and possible homeowner appeal.  See the real estate sales page of this website for comprehensive Hickory Cluster resale data covering all 2013-22 resales.  

The house was the subject of almost continuous work from September 2021 through January 2022, and the all-too-frequent blocking of a fire hydrant and resident cars by contractor trucks for hours at a time despite clearly marked fire lanes and a clearly visible fire hydrant.  Hickory Cluster fire lane signs do not say "except for contractors."

The investor team repaired substantial drywall water damage and other deferred maintenance, and remodeled bathrooms and kitchen with trendy, contemporary flat-pack DIY cabinets, fixtures, and hardware, all sadly not Mid-Century Modern in design or color.  The ground floor kitchen was reconfigured to be a more open and space-efficient with a useful pantry barn door, but in a simplistic, boring, white-on-white color scheme contrasted by stainless steel appliances and black fixtures and hardware.  Lack of a breakfast bar as part of the new kitchen cabinet divider waterfall counter top was a missed, but still possible, opportunity.  In the process, priceless original 1960s Fresnel lens ceiling and other light fixtures, original butterfly bathroom fixtures, and original kitchen appliance and cabinet components were lost forever rather than offered for reuse to other homeowners. 

Contractors refinished and repaired original Hope steel-frame awning and casement windows and original aluminum frame sliding glass doors, but they also absurdly painted the originally removable awning window screen units to the fixed window frames.  Both types of operable windows and the sliding glass doors will require eventual replacement with more modern alternatives to prevent typical excessive air infiltration and heat loss.  The contractors also added a trendy rear patio high-smoke fire ring sure to be popular with nearby neighbors.  New mixed warm white and cold blue ceiling lights will need overall color consistency, typically on the warm side.  Replacement of the old front main entry door house number plaque with a new and original-design-consistent plaque was a good thing, however, painting the replacement front entry white-anodized window aluminum door and window frames foolishly made previously paint-free elements now regular maintenance items requiring paint to match.

Hardwood floors throughout were significantly repaired and refinished, as was the rear patio brick surface.  The investor removed and replaced original ground floor wood parquet tiles attached by black mastic asbestos adhesive with dark tiles that can provide passive solar heating, but laid diagonally rather than orthogonally as did International Style Goodman.  This was a huge mistake.  Goodman used wood for at least one good reason:  concrete slab floors are and feel VERY cold during Winter months, and wood provided much less heat loss than denser vinyl or tile.  So now to compensate, the new homeowner must buy large and expensive rugs, which of course defeat passive solar heating by shielding the tiles from direct sunlight.  Or, as other homeowners did before not after floor material replacement, the investor could have installed a radiant floor heating system between the slab and new tile.  Or, he could have simply refinished the wood tiles as have many other Goodman House homeowners.  And then there's the issue of possible asbestos fiber contamination if not properly managed during tile removal.

Also sadly, it appears the RA resale inspection and disclosure document team neglected to fully follow its own Design Guidelines, Maintenance & Use Standards, and HCA Cluster Standards during both 2021 and 2022 resales of this home.  Such negligence results in unfair treatment of other HCA homeowners who were previously cited for and invested in repairing the very same non-compliant conditions elsewhere, including:  rear mid-level non-original as-built design gutter and downspout addition, upper roof deck non-original as-built design replacement light fixture, and rear top concrete beam black mildew caused by a seriously overgrown tree next door.  In addition, rear patio staggered board fences are non-compliant designs according to current HCA General Resolution 6 Fence Standards, an RA Cluster Standard, which allows four specific options, and the standard does not allow exposed hinge hardware.  According to previous HCA legal counsel guidance, such violations persist whether cited or not, and new homeowners inherit related remediation liability.  RA and HCA standards inspection and disclosure negligence also contributes to a growing accumulation of non-compliant elements, and a death spiral in individual and community Goodman House architectural integrity.

Regardless, Hickory Cluster continues to benefit from a strong real estate seller market with low supply, high demand, and historically low mortgage rates.  Goodman Houses sell quickly, with large cash down payments, almost sight unseen, and without buyer contingencies.  The overall financial success of this project for the realtor and investor is a reflection of those current conditions.  However, further continuation of this success for all stakeholders will still depend on diligent support of unique original as-built Goodman House architectural integrity by both RA and HCA, and the resulting market appeal and value to enlightened and motivated homebuyers who will pay premium prices to own an original Reston, Mid-Century Modern, Hickory Cluster Goodman House.

Monday, June 22, 2020

VANTAGE HILL INFILL PROJECT DRB MTG @ TUE JUN 23

Reston developed Vantage Hill Cluster condominiums in 1967 to provide non-subsidized affordable workforce housing options.  About eight years ago, the Vantage Hill Condominium Unit Owners Association abandoned its dedicated swimming pool common area due to extensive overall deferred maintenance, insufficient reserves funding, high operating costs, and a gradual transition from owner-occupied to rental units.  Vantage Hill currently contains about 35% rental units within 152 units total, while HCA currently has about 12% rentals within 90 total.  VHCUOA 2019 fees ranged from $35-57 monthly, or $420-680 annually, based on shared condo buildings, infrastructure, and common area.  HCA 2019 fees ranged from about $160-240 monthly, or $1920-2880 annually, based on individual townhome units and 2000-24 Block 3 garage project loan $0-80 monthly payments.  VH 2019 condo sales prices ranged from $140,000-250,000 while HC 2019 townhome sales prices ranged from $399,900-$510,000.  An April 2019 Reston Now article provided an early project report.

To build reserves and fund overdue deferred maintenance and improvement projects, a majority of Vantage Hill homeowners recently agreed to sell their unused 2.12 acre swimming pool common area to a local residential developer Craftmark Homes, who proposes to build up to 31 townhomes, and shift 50 parking spaces to other parts of the property, for which the condo association is projected to receive net proceeds of almost $3,500,000.  Vantage Hill and Craftmark will provide an informational presentation to the Full DRB at its 7:00 p.m. monthly virtual meeting tomorrow, and affected parties may voice their concerns, for which RA made the meeting packet publicly available this morning.   Craftmark mailed required meeting notification letters dated June 2 to 21 HCA and other affected parties directly adjoining Vantage Hill.  In response, neighbors submitted to RA at least 17 individual affected party statements of concerns about building-out dedicated cluster common area to generate revenue, increased building density, reduced open space, street setbacks, traffic, noise, safety, tree removal, storm drainage, animal impacts, and more.

For more June 23 Vantage Hill project application package information, see the following links:
  Developer DRB Application, Attachments
  Vantage Hill Condo Assn. Letter to Owners
  Developer Letter to Affected Parties, Map, List
  Affected Parties Statements of Concern
  Developer Site Plans Proposed
  Developer + Vantage Hill Slide Presentation

To attend the June 23 FDRB virtual Zoom meeting, see the Affected Parties Letter link above and/or the following online access summary:
  Meeting Agenda
  Website:  https://www.zoom.com
  Meeting ID:  956 8866 0759
  Password:  934817

HCA NEW DOOR, WINDOW, OR WALL PROJECT?

To help preserve remaining Hickory Cluster architectural integrity, and to help maintain and increase popular Mid-Century Modern resale property values, HCA requires RA DRB applications and approvals for replacing solid entry doors, solid balcony doors, sliding glass doors, fixed or operable glass windows, concrete block or wood rear patio fences and gates, and other original Goodman House as-built design elements and colors as documented in respective HCA governing documents and RA DRB Design Guidelines, even for some compliant proposed replacements.  The application preparation and submission process also follows a number of important steps.  To help HCA Members understand and successfully complete those steps during and after the 2018 RA Cluster Inspections, HCA developed the application process guide posted above.  Note that the guide describes a best case scenario for a complete application, fully compliant project, and normal RA process times.  In addition, RA recently updated their corresponding application form required for all DRB submissions by all RA homeowners.  For more information, see the HCA website Governing Documents webpage for cluster-specific HCA General Resolution architectural standards that take precedence over RA guidelines, the more general RA DRB Cluster Housing Design Guidelines webpage, and the RA DRB application webpage.

Monday, January 27, 2020

HCA ENTRANCE SIGNS REVIEW MEETING @ WED FEB 26

The HCA Board of Directors invites all Members to join them for a review and discussion of proposed new entrance signage designs and placement at the Lake Anne Reston Museum on Wednesday, February 26, 2020 at 7:00 p.m.  This meeting follows ongoing monthly meeting discussions and a September 16, 2019 request for design suggestions from Members.

Tuesday, December 17, 2019

RESTON HISTORIC BLDG SURVEY MTG @ TUE DEC 17

In 1991, the Virginia Dept. of Historic Resources initiated a Survey and Planning Cost Share Program to assist local governments.  The program also supports the DHR mission to identify cultural resources statewide and record them in the DHR VCRIS digital database.  More than 120 Virginia communities have competed to participate and receive limited matching annual funding, and with DHR have conducted 150-plus projects in every region of the Commonwealth.  As a result, each year the DHR inventory of architectural and archeological resources grows with the addition of more than 4,000 newly recorded properties. 

In 2019, DHR selected Fairfax County to participate in a survey covering all of Reston except within the existing Lake Anne Historic Overlay District as designated by Fairfax County.  DHR thoroughly documented and added Lake Anne Village Center to the Virginia Landmarks Register in 2017, which led to listing in the U.S. National Park Service National Register of Historic Places.  DHR listed Reston overall in 2014.

For the 2019 Reston survey project, DHR will hire expert consultants to photograph, map, and document properties with information about building style, construction date, architectural description, and preliminary evaluation of relative significance.  The sites or buildings can then be nominated to be included in the County Inventory of Historic Sites, the Virginia Landmarks Register, or the National Register of Historic Places.  Although such honorary designations do not ensure a building's survival, Bauhaus Professor and Master Architect Marcel Breuer's 1964 Reston API Building, the only Breuer building in Virginia, was permitted for 2016 demolition primarily because it was not listed within the incomplete and outdated Fairfax County inventory that covered Hunter Mill District sites and buildings through only 1920.  Sadly, the permitted developer replaced the bold modernist Breuer API Building with typical, nondescript, cookie-cutter townhomes.

DHR and Fairfax County will hold a joint public information meeting this evening to kick off the project at RCC Lake Anne at 7:00 p.m.  They will also brief the community on completed survey findings early next year.

Saturday, November 9, 2019

LAKE ANNE FELLOWSHIP HSE DRB MTG @ TUE NOV 12

The project team notified HCA affected party neighbors in a letter dated October 29, 2019 that they requested an RA DRB meeting on November 12, 2019 at 7:00 p.m. at RA Headquarters to " ... present and receive approval of an artistic garage screen as the public art element for the development."  Materials to be presented to DRB and the public on November 12 have been uploaded to the following project team webpage, and any further updates were uploaded there no later than 12:00 noon on November 5:  https://thelandlawyers.sharefile.com/d-saeec020255c4b9a8.  The November 12 DRB Meeting Agenda and Application Packet are available on the RA website.  DRB previously approved site plan and general massing concepts, the overall site plan, New Lake Anne House and associated townhomes architectural drawings, site lighting and signage, and minor modifications and clarifications to prior approvals for retaining walls, site lighting, canopy design, and one approved color. 

Monday, September 16, 2019

HCA ENTRANCE SIGN DESIGN DEADLINE @ SAT OCT 19

As described in the official announcement posted at right and mailed September 13, 2019, the HCA Board of Directors is inviting residents and Member homeowners to submit proposed designs for Maple Ridge Rd. and Hickory Cluster entrance signs.  HCA Block 3 Member Ann Youngren suggested entrance sign design clusterwide participation at the 2018 HCA Annual Meeting.

Although RA has DRB Design Guidelines for Cluster Common Area Signs, HCA previously considered unique non-DRB-compliant designs as part of the 1998 Hickory Cluster Common Area Improvement Project, but the signage portion of the project was not completed and the Maple Ridge south side sign location proposed in 1998 is now an overly active bus stop.  More recently, HCA reserved sign space on north corners of each entrance during 2016-17 landscape projects. 

Also noteworthy are sign designs for other Goodman residential communities in DC, Maryland, and Virginia including Hammond Wood, Hollin Hills, River Park, and Rock Creek Woods. 

Proposed designs should include detailed information such as dimensions, materials, finishes, supports, and whatever else is necessary to explain concepts.  Submission deadline is October 19, 2019 for hardcopy or email to:
HCA VP Matt Collins at 11522 Maple Ridge or mattcollins@hickorycluster.org
HCA Director Sylvia Merrill at 11541 Hickory Cluster or sylviamerrill@hickorycluster.org.

Friday, August 30, 2019

LAKE ANNE FELLOWSHIP HSE DRB MTG @ TUE SEP 17

The project team notified HCA affected party neighbors in a letter dated August 28, 2019 that they requested an RA DRB meeting on September 17, 2019 at 7:30 p.m. at RA Headquarters to " ... present and receive approval of minor modifications and clarifications to the prior approvals for retaining walls, site lighting, canopy design, and one approved color."  DRB previously approved site plan and general massing concepts, the overall site plan, New Lake Anne House and associated townhomes architectural drawings, and site lighting and signage.  Materials to be presented to DRB and the public on September 17 have been uploaded to the following project team webpage, and any further updates will be uploaded there no later than 12:00 noon on September 10:  https://thelandlawyers.sharefile.com/d-saeec020255c4b9a8.  UPDATE ... In a letter dated September 24, RA DRB formally approved this Fellowship House proposal.

Friday, August 23, 2019

RESTON, GOODMAN, HICKORY BOOK TALK @ WED SEP 18

CityLab Senior Editor Amanda Kolson Hurly will discuss her new book Radical Suburbs:  Experimental Living on the Fringes of the American City at a September 18, 2019 RCC Lake Anne Rose Gallery event sponsored by the Reston Historic Trust and Museum.  Ms. Hurly, who specializes in architecture and urban planning, also recently discussed another major planned community and book chapter in a similar program at the Greenbelt Museum on July 18, 2019.

In Radical Suburbs, Ms. Hurly writes about Reston in Chapter 6:  The Fight Over the Soul of a New Town, from origins through recent developments, and mentions both Architect Charles M. Goodman and Hickory Cluster: " ... Two prominent architects from Washington filled in the edges of Lake Anne Village with more small-scale Modernist housing.  Charles Goodman, the designer of nearby Hollin Hills, produced Hickory Cluster, ninety townhouses tucked gently into a wooded hillside overlooking the lake.  The houses vary in size and height, but they all bear the same grid in front, a concrete frame that is sometimes enclosed with large panes of glass, sometimes left open as a patio. ... "  Ms. Hurley also quotes Goodman in her Conclusion chapter. 

In another similar book published in 2013, Covert Capital:  Landscapes of Denial and the Making of U.S. Empire in the Suburbs of Northern Virginia, author and Haverford College Assistant Professor of History Andrew Friedman writes about Reston, Goodman, and Hickory Cluster as notable elements of the Dulles Corridor between CIA Headquarters and Dulles International Airport where foreign service lives, places, and architecture merged as professional and personal community expressions of modern, post-World War II, post-colonial, U.S. foreign policy promoted by the CIA.  The book also mentions former HCA Block 3 Member homeowner and CIA Officer Karl Ingebritsen who passed away August 16, 2019.

Both books confirm the noteworthy roles Reston, Goodman, Hickory Cluster, and local residents have played and continue to play in international, national, and regional policy, culture, and history.

Friday, April 26, 2019

HCA TREE DOWNED BY TORNADO WINDS @ FRI APR 19

According to a NOAA National Weather Service damage estimate revised upward yesterday by the local forecaster, a tornado with up to 75 mph. winds damaged Reston homes and trees at about 8:55 p.m. Friday night, April 19 along a four mile, 100 yd. wide, radar-tracked path between Fairfax County and Reston Parkways.
 
Strong associated inflow winds also downed a 33 in. diameter Red Oak tree in Hickory Cluster ... No. 17 within the 2016 HCA Tree Risk Assessment summary and map ... just northwest of HCA Block 1 Group 5 Goodman Houses.  The tree was evaluated by the HCA Consulting Arborist in 2016 to have High combined failure probability and target impact risk ratings due to trunk decay indicated by initial sounding tests, and was pending further arborist testing and recommendations.  Fortunately, the tree caused no reported property damage or injuries and did not block Maple Ridge Rd.  HCA will remove the downed tree at a future date.  Similar winds also downed a large nearby treetop along Fairway Dr. at Hook Rd.

Tuesday, February 5, 2019

RA CLUSTER RE-INSPECTIONS @ MAR 15+

RA Covenants Administration informally advised HCA this afternoon that:  " ... We will be sending a new round of "intent to inspect" letters to (Hickory Cluster) homeowners that have open violations remaining from the (April 2018 RA Cluster Inspection) walkthrough.  We'll be inspecting some time after March 15 (2019), weather permitting.  These inspections will be specifically focused on open violations, not complete property inspections.  We are looking to see if we can close violations ... open for months."

(RA is) " ... working with about 56 homes (or almost 2/3 of all Hickory Cluster Goodman Houses).  There are 24 (homes) that have just one or two open violations so we want to give them every opportunity to clear these up before the re-inspection.  The letter ... will ask for an update.  The next group (about 26 homes) has between three and nine open violations.  There are six (homes) that have ten or more violations so they will likely be called to a Covenants Committee meeting quickly after the re-inspection."  (One Block 2 home) " ... had 19 violations from the walkthrough and that number is down to nine. ... "  During the 2018 inspections, RA also identified but has not yet formally cited HCA for 18 mostly Refuse and Debris standards Common Area violations, many of which appear to be caused over the years by nearby homeowners or contractors.  HCA Directors are discussing how to correct and budget for these Common Area violations.  Failure to correct April 2018 RA Cluster Inspection open violations after an RA Covenants Committee meeting and final deadline may result in further RA actions.  UPDATES ... March 6:  ... " ... Weather permitting, (RA Covenants Advisor inspectors will be) ... out there next Friday ... (March 15) ... .  We've been able to bring the number down to 42 (from 56) properties with 21 of those having just one or two open violations.  Our Covenants Committee team is taking over the inspections of six properties that have ten or more violations ... ."

Saturday, January 26, 2019

RA DRB RELEASES NEW APPLICATION FORM

RA Covenants Administration recently advised HCA that " ... DRB Staff has revised the DRB Application homeowners use when applying to make improvements. This does not affect any applications currently submitted. ... Please let us know if you notice any problems, misspellings, or parts of the form that do not function correctly." 

RA DRB application approval and compliance with HCA and RA standards is required prior to most exterior changes and private property tree removals proposed by HCA Member Goodman House homeowners.  More specific HCA exterior cluster standards enforced by RA are documented within HCA General Resolutions.  Related RA and HCA reference documents are available here and on the HCA Governing Documents webpage, as follows: 
RA Design Review Overview
RA Designs General Information
RA Cluster Housing Design Guidelines
RA Application and Review Procedures
RA Submitting An Application
RA DRB Application Form ... February 5, 2019 version
HCA RA DRB Application Process ... draft

Sunday, December 16, 2018

RESTON LAVC ARCHITECT CONKLIN PASSES

Architect William J. Conklin, who along with late professional partners Julian H. Whittlesey and James S. Rossant designed Lake Anne Village Center, passed away in Maryland on November 22, 2018 at age 95 as reported this week by the New York Times and the Washington Post.  Along with Hickory Cluster designed by Conklin local contemporary Charles M. Goodman, the Village Center is part of the original Reston First Village envisioned by late Reston Founder Robert E. Simon, Jr.  Conklin was profiled in a 1982 American Architecture Now video interview and a Winter 2011 Reston Magazine article.  He studied architecture under modernist Bauhaus School founder Walter Gropius at Harvard University as did retired architect, HCA Block 3 Member, and former HCA Director Ralph Youngren.  Conklin is shown at far right in the photo along with former New York Governor Nelson A. Rockefeller, former New York Mayor John V. Lindsay, and late Architect Philip C. Johnson.  Whittlesey passed away in 1995, Rossant in 2009, and Simon in 2015.

Monday, September 17, 2018

LAKE ANNE FELLOWSHIP HSE FINAL PUBLIC MTGS

The project team will make final presentations to both RA DRB and the Fairfax County Planning Commission and Board of Supervisors starting this week.  Additional public comments will be allowed at these meetings, but site and building conceptual designs are already substantially complete.  Adjacent townhome schematic building site and elevation concepts now include numerous revisions based on extensive public meeting feedback from Hickory Cluster former Block 3 Director Ralph Youngren FAIA, Block 2 Director Michael Poss, and Block 1 Director Michael Smith.  Updates below are current as of October 31.

RA DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MEETING
@ 7:00 P.M. TUE SEP 18
From a letter dated August 28, 2018:  " ... The Applicant will present materials prepared by the Applicant's architect and civil engineer representing the final layout and architecture of the senior multi-family building and the single-family attached dwelling units.  It is anticipated that this meeting will be the final meeting before the Design Review Board prior to the public hearings schedule in October. ... "  DRB approved the conceptual site plan and massing in July.  DRB also approved related September 18 meeting submission items.

COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION
@ 7:30 P.M. THU OCT 4
COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
@ 3:30 P.M. THU OCT 15
From a Legal Notice dated September 13, 2018:  " ... to approve the PRC plan and to permit residential development.  ... to amend the proffers, conceptual and development plans ... previously approved for senior housing to permit an independent living facility and single-family attached units and associated modifications to proffers and site design at a density of 46.3 dwelling units per acre ... ."

RA DESIGN REVIEW BOARD WORK SESSION
@ 1:15 P.M. FRI OCT 26
From a letter dated October 5, 2018:  " ... the Applicant will present a sample board of exterior colors and materials, architectural elevation drawings, and other site development details ... ."

RA DESIGN REVIEW BOARD MEETING
@ 7:00 P.M. TUE NOV 13
From a letter dated October 26, 2018:  " ... materials (presented during the October 26 Work Session) will be revised in accordance with the discussion at the work session and presented to the DRB for a final decision ... ."

Previous project updates are posted below.  Official presentation materials are available on the project team webpage.

Friday, February 23, 2018

RA HCA CLUSTER INSPECTIONS @ MAR 23+

In 2008, RA conducted visual exterior inspections of all 90 HCA Goodman Houses as requested by the HCA Board of Directors.  This resulted in a clusterwide flurry of home clean-up and repair that improved overall cluster appearance and property values for many years thereafter.

In 2018, RA will perform exterior visual walkthrough inspections of Hickory, Waterview, and Burchfield Woods Clusters, as requested by respective Boards of Directors, and according to RA schedules. 

HCA specifically requested in 2018 that RA focus on a limited number of less comprehensive Goodman House exterior items with high visibility property value impacts for which existing condition corrections are reasonably achievable by homeowners.  However, RA advised that its staff teams will perform inspections according to established RA processes, RA standards, and RA checklists used throughout Reston, without HCA-requested limits. 

Assistance for exterior home repairs may be available from RA Helping Homes, an on-going community service project, to eligible HCA Members who are who are elderly, disabled, or financially challenged and are unable to make those repairs through their own resources.  In 2016, RA Helping Homes provided assistance to four Reston homeowners.

For more information and most recent updates and revisions, including 2018 product equivalents and recommendations for 1993-98 HCA Cluster Standards colors, paints, and concrete beam coatings, see the dedicated HCA RA Cluster Inspections webpage. 

UPDATES ... April 24:  For more information about RA violation letter items cited, contact RA Covenants Advisor Vern James.  April 23:  The March 2018 v1.0 "color palette" paint and coating product equivalents reference page RA provided in April 19, 2018 violations letters is an early version, it contains errors later corrected in the March 28, 2018 current version, and HCA asked RA on March 29 to replace it.  The current version is available on the HCA Governing Documents page on this website.

Friday, February 16, 2018

LAKE ANNE FELLOWSHIP HOUSE UPDATES

August 28:  FH requested a 7:00 p.m. September 18 DRB Final Design Approval meeting.  The FH project team has posted these and previous presentation materials, including proposed schematic building and landscape plans, to a dedicated project webpage. 

July 31:  FH requested a 6:00 p.m. August 21 DRB Work Session to discuss proposed site plan revisions and new townhome architectural designs.
 
July 24:  HCA received the RA DRB July 17 full Board meeting decision letter.  Revised FH townhome concept is for 36 units.

July 2:  Next FH presentation at RA DRB is 7:00 p.m. Tuesday, July 17 for approval of a site plan and general building massing, hopefully with June 19 DRB townhome feedback. 

May 29:  FH notified HCA of a 7:00 p.m. Tuesday, June 19 RA DRB public meeting to request approval of a site plan and general massing plan at RA Headquarters. 

May 4:  The project team notified affected HCA Mermbers via letter of a 12:00 noon scheduled work session with RA DRB on Friday, May 25 at RA Headquarters.  Previous sessions were open to the public.  Also,  the applications are currently scheduled on October 4 before the County Planning Commission and October 16 before the Board of Supervisors. 

April 13:  RA announced today that the Tuesday, April 17 DRB working session with the Fellowship House redevelopment team at RA Headquarters is scheduled for 6:00 to 7:00 p.m., one hour earlier than the normal DRB 7:00 p.m. start time.  In addition, a video of the April 6 redevelopment team informational presentation to RA DRB is available online.  Several HCA Members and Directors attended the April 6 meeting. 

March 29:  The snowstorm-cancelled March 20 RA DRB information session is rescheduled for Friday, April 6 from 12:00 to 1:00 p.m. at RA Headquarters.  In addition, a working session is scheduled for the regular Tuesday, April 17 DRB meeting also at RA. 

February 27:  The project team verbally reported that the next community outreach meeting is scheduled for 7:30 p.m. Thursday, March 15 at Lake Anne Elementary School for HCA and Lake Anne Condo residents, and Fairfax County distributed formal notices on March 7.  In addition, the project team mailed Affected Party notification letters  on February 27 to HCA Members advising of the 7:00 p.m. March 20 DRB informational meeting at RA Headquarters with a direct public link to related DRB general presentation slides and Phase 1-3 initial architectural, landscape, and site drawings.  From that DRB meeting material, HCA distilled selected Phase 3 slides and drawings specifically relevant to adjacent HCA Block 1 Affected Neighbors.

RA announced February 16 that the New Lake Anne House LP project team will provide an informational presentation to the full DRB on Tuesday, March 20, 2018.  The February 2018 RA Reston Development Tracker also noted related events:  Fairfax County Staff Report available July 4, Planning Commission hearing July 19, and Board of Supervisors hearing July 31.  In addition, the team selected an undisclosed prominent home builder with Fairfax County experience as developer of up to 70 four-story single family homes to be built immediately adjacent to HCA Block 1 within four years. 

The project team recently surveyed and marked the HCA shared property line with tall wooden stakes and pink marking tape, and marked trees with metal tags and colored tape.

Friday, February 9, 2018

HCA / RA / COUNTY PROHIBIT SHORT-TERM RENTALS

Several years ago, an Airbnb short-term rental of a Hickory Cluster Goodman House caused an uproar from nearby neighbors and much discussion and legal research by the HCA Board of Directors.  In response to similar situations throughout the community, more recently Reston Association established a Home-Sharing Policy based on current Fairfax County rules and Zoning Ordinances, summarized as follows:  " ... Reston has a duty to its Members to enforce the covenants and restrictions put in place to preserve the character and serenity that has made Reston the community it is today.  As the County has now officially determined that short-term rentals violate the Zoning Ordinance, Reston has a duty to enforce the covenants incorporating the Zoning Ordinance and to take action against Members in violation thereof. ... "  To align with current County and RA policies, and to protect very limited HCA Common Area parking from transient tenant "free parking on premises" impacts, HCA Directors agreed during the January 2018 Regular Meeting to prohibit unauthorized HCA short-term rentals.  HCA Members can file formal compliance complaints with Fairfax County as advised in the notice above, or in writing with RA or HCA.  UPDATE ... March 20:  The Fairfax County Board of Supervisors authorized public hearings for proposed new zoning rules on short-term lodgings, such as those offered through Airbnb, VRBO and Flipkey.  Please note the following dates are subject to change:  Planning Commission Public Hearing on May 3, 2018 at 7:30 p.m., and Board of Supervisors Public Hearing on June 19, 2018 at 4:00 p.m.  For more information, see the recent County press release.

Thursday, November 30, 2017

LAKE ANNE FELLOWSHIP HOUSE INFO MTG @ DEC 11

Earlier this week HCA Directors and Members received letters announcing a 7:00 p.m. December 11, 2017 meeting at Lake Anne Elementary School hosted by Fairfax County Supervisor Hudgins to share current redevelopment project information with Hickory Cluster and Waterview Cluster residents prior to future broader community meetings.  RA also reported November 17 that the New Lake Anne House LP project team submitted Fairfax County Planning and Zoning applications on November 8.  Apparently the County received the applications but did not formally accept them for review.  The current Comprehensive Plan permits multi-family residential development of no more than 320 multi-family dwelling units on this 5.96 acre site.  This implies that up to 80 new units will be built in addition to replacements for 240 existing senior citizen affordable housing units, assuming current zoning density limits are not increased as has been the subject of recent community meeting heated public debate.  A redevelopment partner also indicated that new residential buildings along the Hickory Cluster Block 1 property line will be four stories tall, and that in response to July 2017 HCA general concerns " ... We are endeavoring to design the development to minimize impact to Hickory Cluster and these new plans certainly have less impact than the previous plans developed several years ago. ... "  See earlier HCA website posts for more background information.