Showing posts with label meetings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label meetings. Show all posts

Thursday, June 22, 2023

HCA REVISED GOV DOCS APPROVAL FAILS ... AGAIN

With absentee ballots due to TWC by a 12:00 noon deadline, and in-person voting available at an RCC Lake Anne June 21, 2023 Special Meeting from 7:00 to 7:30 p.m., a growing number of voting HCA Members again declined to approve drastically revised HCA Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws, this time v4.  The final numbers:

All v4 votes counted:            47 or 52.22% of 90 possible, vs. 32 for v3

Absentee v4 votes:               41 or 87.23% of all votes

In-person v4 votes:                 6 or 12.77% of all votes

Votes FOR v4 approval:         19 or 40.43% of all votes, vs. 21 for v3

Votes AGAINST v4 approval:   28 or 59.57% of all votes, vs. 12 for v3

The HCA official website incorrectly reports only 20 v4 Against votes.  However, HCA Counsel who managed the vote count at the meeting reported 28 total Against votes.  In-person Against votes were definitely known to be at least two.  Emailed or USPS-mailed Against votes were definitely known to be at least 24, and apparently totaled 26 based on actual results.

One absentee ballot was submitted with a box-marking defect that was not cured and therefore not counted before voting closed at 7:30 p.m.  In addition, two Members, ostensibly one voting For and one voting Against the v4 documents, arrived after the 7:30 p.m. Special Meeting end voting deadline and were unable to cast their ballots.  The additional but late Against vote would have totaled only two votes short of a completely insurmountable 31/90 = 34.44% disapproval vote.

As expected, the number of v4 Against votes increased from the v3 Against votes because the Board continued to insist on approval of major changes increasing Board power and convenience to which many Members do NOT agree, including non-homeowner Director eligibility, unilateral rule change power that circumvents the long-standing Member-inclusive Special Resolution 2 process still in effect, and more.  

What next?  HCA Counsel says the HCA Board tells them what they WANT counsel to do.  The HCA Board says Counsel tells them what the Board SHOULD do.  After all the finger-pointing is done, to increase support the Board must remove persisting offending major changes rather than criticize opposing Members, acknowledge valid Member efforts to preserve viable and long-standing Hickory Cluster governing documents, and act on valid Member concerns about persisting issues.  Former HCA President Michael Poss and concerned Block 1 Member Carol Laird will again, as they have in previous months, provide related feedback to the Board as requested in another attempt to move forward with remaining unresolved issues.

Saturday, June 17, 2023

HCA REVISED GOV DOCS v4 ... DANGEROUS = AGAIN: NO

On one hand, the Board heard, again, and finally and commendably incorporated several suggestions from Members at the May 2023 Annual Meeting to be voted upon by HCA Members on or before a scheduled June 21 Special Meeting.

On the other hand, the Board apparently is using incomplete information to justify unlimited new powers to more easily make significant decisions that could dangerously impact Member rights and property.  And they continue to pursue an all-or-nothing approach rather than voting on individual issues.

Here are links to the current v4 documents with yellow-highlighted areas denoting, but not limited to, the following remaining unresolved issues:

PROPOSED REVISED ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION v4

1.  Unlimited fines for rules violations, page 5, Article III 3. c. ... VERY DANGEROUS:  "The Board of Directors may ... impose monetary charges when there exists a violation of any of the provisions of the Governing Documents or the Rules and Regulations." This could be financially devastating to retired homeowners on limited incomes.

2.  Unlimited power to establish charges for Common Area use, page 5, Article III 3. d. ... Members could be charged for parking and other uses.

3.  Unlimited "preferential" allocation by Board of Common Area use, page 5, Article III 3. d. ... What is the real intent of the new weasel word "preferential" vs. the previous weasel word "unequal"  And "preferential" implies that some Members may be more equal than others.

4.   Unlimited rules changes by Board, page 5, Article III 3. d. ... VERY DANGEROUS:  "Rules and Regulations may be amended or repealed by the Board of Directors at any time."  This new text gives the Board overwhelming and possibly abusive authority to change any rule at any time, with no notice or Member feedback.  Currently, General Resolutions rules and regulations changes can only be made after sufficient notice to and feedback from Members within a clearly defined process, including an announced public Member hearing, described in HCA Special Resolution 2:  Creation, Modification, and Deletion of Rules.

5.  Six-month time limit for catastrophic damage repair, page 6, Article IV 4. ... DANGEROUS:  This is an impossible deadline, considering major externally-controlled legal, administrative, contractor, and supply issues impacting catastrophe recovery.  A recent lengthy Block 2 rowhouse recovery project is but one example.  This limit also makes quickness a higher priority than quality work, full scope, or prohibitive expense.

6.  Non-owner household members can be HCA Directors, page 6, Article VI ... VERY DANGEROUS:  "The Board of Directors shall be composed of seven (7) persons, all of whom shall be Members of the Association or members of the Member's household ... ."  ONLY vested homeowners-of-record should govern OTHER homeowners of record.  NON-homeowner adult children, spouses, or tenants should NOT have that power.  The Board attorney's larger-candidate-pool-is-better argument is a deceptive half-truth.  HCA has virtually ALWAYS had seven Directors in place as outcomes of annual meetings.  And actual HCA practice is that of surprise "ambush" nominations and other pre-planned and pre-supported actions AT, not before, annual meetings themselves, to strategically limit competition or opposition.  Rarely do candidates announce their intentions BEFORE the meetings, and if they do they risk petty opposition.  Example:  At the 2023 annual meeting, an end-term Director publicly withheld their real intention to seek re-election until AT the annual meeting itself, not before, effectively thwarting other candidates.  So in reality, there were FIVE candidates for THREE vacancies, not just ONE candidate as the Board cover letter FAQs and document footnotes deceivingly stated.

PROPOSED REVISED BYLAWS v4

1.  Unlimited power to establish charges for Common Area use, page 2, Article I 2. l. ... See Articles same issue above

2.  Unlimited "preferential" allocation by Board of Common Area use, page 2, Article I 2. l. ... See Articles same issue above

3.  Unlimited rules changes by Board, page 2, Article I 2. l. ... VERY DANGEROUS:  See Articles same issue above

4.  Unlimited proxy form manipulation by Board, page 5, Article III 7. (b) ...  DANGEROUS:  The current Board has manipulated the last few elections one way or another, as outlined in earlier posts on this website.  This gives the Board additional options for manipulating proxy forms to eliminate non-Director proxies and other devices to promote a Board-preferred slate of candidates. One example:  requiring all candidates to nominate BEFORE the annual meeting, and then extending the nomination period to other preferred candidates AFTER they know who pre-nominated.  It will most likely be anti-competitive and unfair to candidates who do not agree with the status quo.

5.  Unlimited Common Area modification by Board, page 6, Article IV 2. (b) ... VERY DANGEROUS:  Current Bylaws require a 2/3 affected neighbor approval of Common Area changes, except for emergency or preventive repairs.  But even that has not stopped recent past Boards from planting big trees that will grow into homes or block their windows.  Removing the current restriction will make the situation even worse because there will be NO restrictions on what the Board can do immediately adjacent to your Goodman House without your knowledge or input.

6.  Non-owner household members can be HCA Directors, page 6, Article IV 3. (a) ... VERY DANGEROUS:  See Articles same issue above

7.  Unlimited Director candidate manipulation by Board, page 6, Article IV 3. (a) ...  DANGEROUS:  The current Board has manipulated the last few elections one way or another, as outlined in earlier posts on this website.  This gives the Board additional options for now-officially recruiting and promoting their own Board-preferred slate of candidates.  It will most likely be anti-competitive and unfair to candidates who do not agree with the status quo.

8.  Unlimited amount of Lot repair charges to Members by Board, page 11, Article VIII 1. (a) ... VERY DANGEROUS:  "Charges incurred by the Association in performing exterior maintenance on the Lot as permitted by the Reston Deed will be considered an assessment and collectible as such."  This is new to the HCA Bylaws and could possibly be financially devastating to retired homeowners on limited incomes, even if actually allowed by the Reston Deed.

RECOMMENDATION:  Until these proposed dangerous revisions are resolved, continue to vote AGAINST the proposed revised documents.

Monday, May 8, 2023

HCA REVISED GOV DOCS ... SECOND "FINAL" VOTE?

UPDATED MAY 13, 2023
                                                                                                                  After the HCA Board of Directors failed to get approval from 2/3 of March 8, 2023 voting Members, they plan to hold yet another "final" vote on the very same defective revised Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws, initially at the 2023 HCA Annual Meeting on May 20, 2023.  

However, a TWC letter dated May 9, 2023, mailed May 11, and received May 13, stated that" ... The agenda listed the by-law amendment voting but we are doing that at a separate meeting. ... Notice will be provided to the community prior to holding the vote again."

This new vote, whenever it is held, appears to be an attempt to disregard and negate the March 8 vote because, as one Director is reported to have commented, Members did not really read the revised documents.  

On the contrary, knowledgeable Members DID read the revisions.  And as a result, those Members voted AGAINST the revisions.

So if Members again defeat the defective revised documents, will HCA hold a Final Final Final vote?  

Or if they are approved, will opponents also get a do-over as did the Board?

As before, Members who have fully studied them urge a vote AGAINST the defective revised governing documents.

For previous related posts, and details on the many issues with the proposed governing documents revisions, visit the following webpage and others published below.

Wednesday, May 3, 2023

HCA REVISED GOV DOCS v3 APPROVAL FAILS

As announced in a letter notice dated February 3, 2023, HCA held a Special Meeting for the purpose of voting on the "Amended and Restated Bylaws and Articles of Amendment and Restatement" ... AKA:  revised governing documents ... on Wednesday, March 8, 2023, from 7:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m. at the RCC Lake Anne Rose Gallery.  This was planned to be for voting only, and not as another town hall or discussion.

And as stated in the Special Meeting Absentee Ballot Instructions, "Ballots submitted before the special meeting are to be submitted no later than 5:00 p.m. on March 7, 2023 ... " to TWC via email, mail, or hand delivery, even though TWC main entry doors remained locked throughout the day requiring extraordinary Member efforts to get TWC staff to take their hand delivered absentee ballots.

After considerable debate during the March 8 meeting, HCA and attendees agreed that only Absentee Ballots submitted before that date and time deadline would be counted.  In addition, only non-absentee attendee Member ballots submitted during the 7:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m. March 8 live meeting period would be counted.

HCA criteria for revised governing document approval was more than a 2/3 "For" vote from all votes cast, NOT on 2/3 of all 90 Goodman House votes, as ostensibly allowed by the Virginia Property Owners Association Act (POAA).  Therefore, with a 1/5 x 90 = 18 Member minimum absentee plus meeting quorum, the revised governing documents affecting all 90 Goodman House Members could unfortunately be approved by only 1/5 x 90 = 18 quorum x 2/3 = 12 + 1 = 13 Member votes out of 18 minimum total votes.

After it appeared that all in-person votes had been submitted, HCA interest in staying until 9:00 p.m. for late voters faded.  So HCA asked, and Members approved by a clear majority vote, adjournment to a Thursday, March 9 Zoom virtual meeting to be held solely for the purpose of announcing absentee and live meeting vote results.  HCA left blank ballots at the RCC front desk with written instructions to drop off or email any additional votes before the announced 9:00 p.m. meeting end deadline.

Just before adjournment, current HCA legal counsel counted 21 "For" votes, and 11 "Against" votes, for a total of 32 votes and 65.63% approval value, just short of the >66.67% required.  And according to one HCA Member, a 12th "Against" vote was recorded before the 9:00 p.m. deadline.

Stuff happens.  The Zoom meeting did not happen, for technical reasons beyond immediate Board control.  However, the Board did adjourn the continuation Zoom meeting and post the results on the official HCA website.  

FINAL RESULTS:  As posted on the HCA website, 21 "For" votes, 12 "Against" votes, resulting in a 64.71% approval value, still short of the required >66.67% required.  Therefore, the existing 1964 Articles of Incorporation, and the1993 Revised Bylaws, remain in force.

POSSIBLE PATH FORWARD:  As Henry Ford said, " ... begin again, this time more intelligently."  One collaborative path would be to make ONLY required legal and document de-conflictions updates.  Leave the remaining long-standing HCA text alone.  Gain opposing Members' support as a result.  Then vote again.  If not, both increased support AND increased opposition may cause a similar outcome.

For previous related posts, and details on the many issues with the proposed governing documents revisions, visit the following webpage and others published below.

Monday, March 6, 2023

HCA REVISED GOV DOCS v3 STILL FAULTY ... AGAIN: NO

VOTE AGAINST the proposed revised HCA Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws at the March 8, 2023 Special Meeting or by Absentee Ballot. 

Here's why, the short version:

The proposed revisions are NOT just minor legal "updates" to "modernize" "outdated" versions and de-conflict multiple governing documents.

The "multiple footnotes" do not identify or explain all deletions and additions.

The revisions include major deletions and additions that broadly INCREASE Board unilateral authority and control, and that broadly DECREASE Member collaborative involvement, rights, and protections.

Here's why, the longer version:

"Sir, hell is paved with good intentions."                                                       - Samuel Johnson, 1775

The HCA Board of Directors may have good intentions, but unfortunately it appears that those intentions have been misguided in an effort to "modernize" HCA governing documents.  This post provides an alternative perspective based on more than 15 years of HCA Member, HCA Director, and HCA Corporate Officer experience using, authoring, and managing HCA governing documents.  

HCA governing documents are more than just legal documents.  They embody historic and time-tested Reston and HCA homeowner visions and traditions.  Those historic visions and traditions are worth preserving even if minor legal or multiple document de-confliction updates are required.

Sadly, HCA visions and traditions were NOT the focus of the 2022-23 HCA Board of Directors.  Instead of forming Member-Director working groups to collaboratively develop community-focused revisions as was done during the last major Bylaws revision effort in the early 1990s, the Board mostly outsourced the task to a newly-retained law firm, and then asked for Member feedback AFTER the fact.

Here are comments from several Members who attended the October 2022 Town Hall Meeting discussion of proposed revisions v2:

"It was a town hall stone wall."

"That lawyer was very unwilling to compromise on anything.  She was not even willing to agree that a board director has to be over (age) 18!  I guess we'll see what they decide to put out there. ... "

"In spite of obviously many hours working these issues ... I did not hear the lawyer one time endorse any suggestion ... .  Many times she cited an extreme example to support her position.  It was always "cited" or taken under advisement.  There is enough bureaucratic wordsmithing here to choke a horse.  She seemed reluctant to even include a few words about the source of material.  We seem to have several documents such as a deed, POAA, etc, etc, which supersede each other.  It is confusing to me precisely what we are trying to update and why actually.  Did the existing documents not work well?  As ... said, just have one page that says let the Board do what they want.  It looks like an effort to simplify/"modernize" which seems to me would make the Board's job harder due to a lack of specific language.  As ... said, language that has served us well for sixty years could/should be left in.  Taking things out like having an annual meeting in May for example make no practical sense.  To me an update should be more specific based on experience on what has worked instead of deleting language to simplify. ... Some additions about bids, who can become a director, use of common area simply defy common sense. ... When ... posed several questions to the Board they just blew them off and seemed very defensive.  Even if TWC is charged with getting all bids, if true, they should have to follow our guidelines seems to me.  They do work for us I think!  She is obviously a talented lawyer and is determined to have this her way.  I am not convinced she really has the interests of the cluster at heart.  She seems determined to fashion an update to reflect her views. ... "

In addition, many HCA Members are new to the cluster and/or have little interest in HCA governing documents let alone working knowledge or experience governing with them as a Director, or being governed by them as a Member.  And they are unaware of the very serious impacts of major changes to the governing documents to which they agreed when they bought their Goodman House.  

More specifically:

v1 proposed revision review comments were reported in a May 2022 post on this website.

v2 proposed revision review comments were reported an October 2022 post on this website. 

v3 March 2023 proposed revisions appear to be the same as the v2 October 2022 proposed revisions, indicating that the author(s) continued to exclude many Member concerns voiced at both the May 2022 and October 2022 town hall meetings.  For reference, here are the v3 documents and corresponding v2/v3 review comments:

PROPOSED NEW ARTICLES v3 FINAL ... complete document                      Revision Comments in Detail ... compared with existing documents            Revisions Summary:

  1.  Removes violation due process hearing details

  2.  Adds Common Area unequal and non-uniform use

  3.  Adds automatic catastrophe repair deadline of six months

  4.  Allows NON-ADULT and NON-HOMEOWNER household members to be Directors and make all Board decisions impacting adult Member homeowners

PROPOSED NEW BYLAWS v3 FINAL ... complete document                              Revision Comments in Detail ... compared  with existing documents            Revisions Summary: 

  1.  Ignores all 18 Special and General Resolutions, including parking regulations, architectural standards, and other key cluster rules that the Board FAILED to formally re-adopt on/before April 2020

  2.  Removes Good Standing and violations due process details, leaving Members more vulnerable to Board decisions

  3.  Allows Common Area unequal and non-uniform use, potentially abusive and inequitable

  4.  Allows unlimited Board use of virtual online meetings, limiting Member interaction when Member microphones can be cut off

  5.  Allows annual meetings any month the Board wants, despite the May tradition since founding

  6.  Allows unlimited Director election proxy vote manipulation, as has occurred when the HCA Secretary or other Director voted numerous unassigned proxy votes with NO transparency as to who they voted for, thus manipulating who is elected Director

  7.  Removes Common Area modification approval by 2/3 affected Members, allowing unwanted large trees to be planted too near homes or other work directly impacting Member homes and property values WITHOUT Member notice let alone agreement

  8.  Allows Director removal by as few as 10 votes (50% + 1 vote of 18 Member minimum quorum), creating significant potential abuse from petty personal vendettas

  9.  Continues Director appointment without giving all Members equal opportunity, encouraging non-transparent sweetheart appointments

  10.  Continues unlimited Director nomination and election process misinformation and manipulation, as has occurred in recent Director elections

  11.  Continues lack of restatement in HCA documents of Executive Session legal requirements that inform both Directors and Members, ensure compliance, and prevent abuse

  12.  Continues lack of annual financial audit report availability to Members as has occurred since 2016

  13.  Allows amateur business judgment instead of a minimum number of bids, increasing the potential for underperformance and overpayment by Directors who are not business professionals, or by overextended managing agents

  14.  Allows Special Assessments of ANY amount with NO Member approval, without identifying possible Member options or recourse, and with past HCA Special Assessments of up to $10,000 or more 

  15.  Allows the Board to repair Member private property, and then bill the Members for the repairs, without adequate due process

  16.  Removes existing detailed and traditional annual dues policy, including possible collection on an other than traditional monthly basis

Again:  HCA needs ONLY required legal updates and document de-confliction, not wholesale revision of traditional HCA governing documents to conform to what the author(s) "regularly see" elsewhere.

Until then:  VOTE AGAINST the proposed Articles and Bylaws revisions.

If you have already voted FOR by Absentee Ballot and now want to change your vote, complete a NEW Absentee Ballot with an AGAINST vote, and with a written date AFTER your original version, to supersede the original.

Monday, October 24, 2022

HCA REVISED GOV DOCS v2 ISSUES + VOTE ... AGAIN: NO

At the September 21, 2022 Regular Meeting, HCA Directors asked attending Members how much time they wanted to review revised Articles/Bylaws v2.  The apparently acceptable response:  30 days minimum.  And they promised redlined change-tracking versions to more clearly identify what text was removed, kept, or added.

The good news:  v2 redlines helped.  As did some requested changes.  Thank you.  

The bad news:  The proposed v2 Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws with a cover letter dated September 22, and postmarked September 27, were received by Members no earlier than September 28.  HCA then announced in a letter dated October 4, postmarked October 4, and received no earlier than October 5, a corresponding October 24 Town Hall meeting.  That gave Members only 19 days from the October 5 earliest actual meeting notice receipt to review and understand massive changes to key, yet typically unfamiliar, governing documents on October 24.  

More bad news: "... amending some of the bylaws of the community. ... "  or even " ... updating the Bylaws ... " to current law, or adding consistency, are not what is really happening here.  HCA removed major governing document sections, added completely new sections, and kept little from known and trusted documents and processes dating back to as early as 1960s HCA creation.  

The following links are to scanned copies of the proposed Articles/Bylaws v2 governing documents, and correspondingly section-keyed review comments added by a long-time resident with years of HCA governing issues and documents working knowledge and experience:

PROPOSED NEW ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION v2                                   (1)  As Proposed by HCA                                                                             (2)  Review Comments

PROPOSED NEW BYLAWS v2                                                                   (1)  As Proposed by HCA                                                                             (2)  Review Comments

You can find the referenced 1964 Articles of Incorporation, 1993 Bylaws, and Special and General Resolutions on the Governing Documents page of this website.

Sadly, many proposed revisions increase Board ability to make major impact cluster decisions without transparent Member notice or approval, ostensibly because most if not all Directors don't have enough time to do all the many things they should be doing to run the cluster.  On the other hand, if you don't have enough time to be a Director, then perhaps you can always step aside and let someone else who has the time, knowledge, and experience be a Director instead.

Examples of serious issues with the new Articles v2 proposed revisions include: removal of violation due process hearing details, adding Common Area unequal and non-uniform use, adding catastrophe repair deadline of six months, allowing non-adult and non-owner household members to be Directors.

And the new Bylaws v2 proposed revisions unfortunately include:  ignoring all 18 Special and General Resolutions, no Good Standing and violations due process details, adding Common Area unequal and non-uniform use, unlimited use of interaction-restricting virtual video meetings, annual meetings any month the Board wants, unlimited proxy vote manipulation, removal of Common Area modification approval by affected Members, allowing Director removal by as few as 10 votes, continued Director appointment without Member opportunity announcement, unlimited Director nomination and election manipulation, lack of Executive Session requirements, continued recent lack of annual financial audit report Member public availability, substituting non-professional business judgment for bid minimums, allowing Special Assessments of any amount with no Member approval, billing Members for Board repairs to their private property, and lack of existing detailed annual dues policy, including possible collection on an other than monthly basis.

That is WAY too much problematic and unresolved stuff.

So because HCA appears to be proposing a quick all-or-nothing vote, and until ALL open issues are resolved, VOTE NO on v2.

Friday, May 27, 2022

HCA DIRECTOR ELECTION MANIPULATED ... AGAIN

Updated May 28, 2022

You would think that after a national spotlight on government election integrity during the past few years even the Hickory Cluster Board of Directors would try hard to avoid real or perceived election irregularities.  And to provide a consistent and fair, if not legal, Director election process as an example of capable cluster management.

Sadly, that did not happen in 2021, and it is about to not happen again in 2022.  Instead, it appears the Board is continuing to manipulate the annual meeting candidate nomination and election process, and is trying to enshrine more of the same manipulation in proposed new versions of HCA bylaws, to ensure election of those candidates the Board likes vs. those it does not. 

Last year was a preview of this year's plan.  You may not have noticed the details then or now, but here's apparently how the 2022 Hickory Cluster Annual Meeting election manipulation works:

1.  SUPPORT NEGATIVE CAMPAIGNING
On a private social media group co-administered by a Director, who also sought re-election after the 2022 initial nomination period closed, support another candidate by allowing them ... someone who has commonly-understood histories of undermining the HCA Board and causing the Cluster added expense during the Block 3 parking garage crisis by triggering its condemnation earlier than the Board planned, and of filing Fairfax County zoning and building code complaints against neighbors ... to publish negative and derogatory half-truths about a third candidate specifically to undermine them, even though that social media private group's "rules" say such posts are not allowed.

2.  ANNOUNCE A PHONY NOMINATION DEADLINE
In a first mailing postmarked April 29, announce a pre-meeting nomination form submission hard deadline of 3:00 p.m. May 12 with no other options for nomination later.  And "forget" to include the nomination form in the mailing, but post the nomination form on the official HCA website with no other direct notice that it is there.  That gives the Board advance knowledge of candidates, only two of which applied on time in compliance with clearly stated May 12 deadline, and an ostensible reason to change the deadline mid-stream.

3.  ANNOUNCE THE SAME PHONY DEADLINE ... AGAIN
In a second mailing postmarked May 9, send out the "missing" nomination form with the original 3:00 p.m. May 12 nomination submission hard deadline stated again, and again with no other options for nomination later.  

4.  RECRUIT MORE CANDIDATES
Review the candidates that complied by the twice-stated May 12 deadline.  If you like the candidates, accept them and send out the meeting packets with only those candidates listed.  If you don't like them, set a new nomination deadline to recruit and allow additional candidates.

5.  ALLOW OTHER CANDIDATES TO NOMINATE LATE
Notify other possible candidates, including Directors who originally decided not to run, or others who publicly stated they missed the original deadline, that they are special and do not have to comply with the original clearly-stated nomination May 12 deadline.

6.  ANNOUNCE A NEW NOMINATION DEADLINE OBSCURELY
On the obscure official HCA website, announce there, but not directly via written notice or in any other way to all Members, that the original nomination hard deadline has been magically changed to May 16.

7.  ALLOW EVEN MORE LATE NOMINATIONS AT THE ANNUAL MEETING ITSELF
In a third mailing meeting packet postmarked May 19, now announce that additional nominations during the Annual Meeting itself ... that were NOT allowed according to the first and second mailing announcements ... can be made.

8.  RESTRICT PROXY VOTING ONLY BY THE HCA SECRETARY
In the same third mailing meeting packet, manipulate the proxy form so that proxies can now be assigned ONLY to the HCA Secretary and NOT to other Members as has been the case in HCA for decades.  Assignment to other Members is NOT restricted by the current HCA Bylaws.  And then continue to allow the HCA Secretary to vote uninstructed proxies ... those without designated candidate voting preferences ... without transparency for the candidates of their choice.

9.  ANNOUNCE TWO PROXY SUBMISSION DEADLINE TIMES
The third mailing meeting packet cover letter clearly states a 2:00 p.m. Friday, May 27 proxy submittal deadline to TWC.  BUT ... the proxy form itself amazingly states a 12:00 noon deadline the same day.  This is nuts.  And could result in disqualified proxies.

10.  REMOVE A CANDIDATE'S STATEMENT SECOND PAGE
The May 9 mailing and official website-posted nomination form clearly stated that candidates " ... may submit your statement on a separate sheet of paper and attach it to this form (up to 2 pages).  The Cluster will distribute your statement to the membership with the official Notice of Annual Meeting. ... ."  And April 29 and May 9 mailing cover letters stated " ... Your Statement of Interest provided will be presented to the members exactly as it is provided to us. ... "  One candidate submitted a TWO page statement as allowed.  But the Board failed to include the second page ... a reference copy of the 2019 HCA proxy form that shows serious discrepancies among the 2019, 2021, and 2022 proxy forms ... to Members in the May 19 third mailing meeting packet as promised.

11.  HOLD THE ELECTION ON A MAJOR HOLIDAY WEEKEND
Many Members and their families will probably be out of town for the typically long Memorial Day weekend, Friday-Monday, May 27-30.  They understandably have better things to do than attend a homeowners meeting.  So that means more votes will be by proxy rather than in person, and therefore controlled by the Board to again potentially determine the election winners.  Previous Boards have specifically NOT held the Annual Meeting and election on a holiday weekend to maximize Member attendance and in-person voting.  Yes, Zoom may increase attendance, but it is just not the same.  Really ... who wants to do that on a holiday at the beach or wherever?

12.  ALLOW CANDIDATES TO BE ABSENT FROM THE ELECTION MEETING
Legal counsel advice to previous Boards maintained that Director candidates MUST be physically present at annual meeting elections to effectively and transparently understand and accept election results.  However, for the first time in more than a decade, at least one candidate was on vacation during the time of the Annual Meeting.  And at least one candidate's statement of interest appears to have been written by someone other than the candidate themselves.

13.  ALLOW ABSENT MEMBER VOTES VIA UNKNOWN ONLINE POLLING TOOL
This adds increased complexity to, and questions about, the election process and results audit trail.  What tool is being used?  Who is managing it?  Are all attendees validated as real Members in general, and in good standing specifically?  Does the system produce complete paper records of attendees and their votes for official records and possible review by all Members?  Are the system and results subject to manipulation during or after use?  And a 2013 legal opinion to HCA stated that email voting, a similar electronic process, was not permitted.

NOTE:  More, including respective reference documents, will be posted soon.  Please check back again.

This is not just a simple mistake or two.   It is more than that.  The Board is apparently trying hard to get the Director election results it wants.  Or it just doesn't know what it is doing.  Either way, it is unfair to everyone involved, if not possibly illegal, and indicates either more bad faith or less competency than is reasonable.  

So the question is:  Are enough HCA Members willing to let this happen now and in the future?  

Next time YOU could be the person NOT preferred by the Board.   

Regardless, those two candidates who filed May 12 on time according to the Boards twice-stated deadline requirements should be directly elected to two open positions because they would not have been subject to a clusterwide vote for them.  The other three candidates who filed late May 15-16 should compete only for the one remaining open position.  

And ... Board manipulation of HCA Director elections, for whatever reason, must stop now.

Sunday, May 15, 2022

HCA REVISED BYLAWS + ARTICLES NEED MORE WORK

Updated May 22, 2022

When it became apparent that the Board had changed the meeting purpose from a discussion-and-vote session to a question-and-answer session, a Block 3 HCA Director stated that the Board did not see the meeting announcement letter before TWC sent it out to Members, and that they posted the change on the official HCA website, which of course no one saw.  An irritated Block 3 Member commented, and other attendees agreed, that the Board should have notified Members directly about the change.  Attendees included six Directors and about six other Members.

A common response to Member questions about document text changes, whether partially-documented new version additions or typically undocumented old version deletions, was that the Board wanted "flexibility," ostensibly to unilaterally do anything, anytime, anywhere, and for any reason.  More soon about the rest of the meeting ...

Updated May 18, 2022

The HCA Board of Directors and their new attorney have been working on governing documents revisions for a year or more with no HCA Member public collaboration as part of that process.  Then Members received a Town Hall discussion and voting meeting announcement and proposed document copies on about May 4, postmarked May 2, and dated April 29.

In response, the Board expects at least 60 Members to discuss and approve a package of significant changes in two major governing documents within only two hours on May 18, 2022 ... after only 14 days of review and consideration ... that would then be used to govern at the 2022 HCA Annual Meeting of Members and beyond.

The initial purpose for these new versions was ostensibly to reconcile and align existing governing documents, including Deed, Articles of Incorporation, and Bylaws, with each other and with current relevant Virginia law.  However, the revised Bylaws contain numerous OTHER changes, many of which were NOT called out with the 2022 text, let alone with the 1993 text, several key 1993 sections were eliminated outright, and some changes have no previous HCA document or practice precedent.

Here are the linked source documents with specific sections of note yellow-highlighted, and related review comments summarized on additional pages:

HCA ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION WITH REVIEW COMMENTS                            1964 Version currently in effect                                                                1993 Proposed Amendments to 1964 Articles ... apprvl undocumented        2022 Version proposed by HCA Board

HCA CORPORATE BYLAWS WITH REVIEW COMMENTS                                        1993 Version currently in effect                                                                2022 Version proposed by HCA Board

Current bottom line:  Because of the large number of problematic sections in the 2022 Proposed Bylaws, and because of key 1993 sections eliminated in the 2022 version, this reviewer recommends a NO vote, or NOT voting at all, UNTIL each problematic item is thoroughly discussed, revised if necessary, and reviewed again for final approval, however long it takes for enduring quality rather than convenient speed.

Monday, January 4, 2021

RESTON HISTORIC BLDG SURVEY MTG @ TUE JAN 5

The Fairfax County Dept. of Planning and Development and Virginia Dept. of Historic Resources survey consultant Hanbury Preservation Consulting has completed their draft report and published it for community review on a Fairfax County webpage.  According to the official meeting agenda, Fairfax County Hunter Mill District Supervisor Walter Alcorn will welcome attendees, and the project team leaders will then brief the Reston community on the project and initial survey findings during a virtual meeting from 7:00 to 8:30 p.m. on Tuesday, January 5, 2021.  HCA Members and others can attend using a WebEx link, or via telephone at (844) 621-3956 with access code 179 469 1739.  The meeting will also stream live on Alcorn's YouTube webpage.  The 2019 kick-off meeting was reported in an earlier post on this website. 

The survey is a key element of Fairfax County's belated response to their tragic and avoidable 2016 approval of demolition of Bauhaus Architect and Professor Marcel Brauer's striking 1964 Reston American Press Institute Building that made way for yet more generic cookie-cutter townhomes.  The API building and many others were not on the County Inventory of Historic Sites because that deficient list then covered buildings only through about 1920.  Architect Charles M. Goodman's 1965 Hickory Cluster was an important focus of the current survey that will be used to inform government agencies and hopefully prevent future losses of early Reston significant Mid-Century Modern Architecture.

Sunday, January 3, 2021

HCA BOD VACANCY NOMINATIONS DUE @ WED JAN 6

At their August 2020 Regular Meeting, HCA Directors appointed two Members as their preferred candidates to fill long-standing vacancies for full unexpired terms after resignations of two former Directors.  Such full-term appointments, however, were contrary to (1) accepted Amendments to the HCA 1964 Articles of Incorporation, proposed and ostensibly approved in late 1993, that allowed unexpired-term appointments to run only until the next scheduled election, and contrary to (2) recent previous Boards' decisions and practices based on acceptance of the amendments.

HCA then announced the election of only two Directors, rather than four (two for expired terms and two for unexpired terms) as required by the 1993 Amendments.  When a long-time Member identified this issue during the pandemic-delayed September 2020 Annual Meeting candidate nomination process, the Board further delayed the meeting to October 2020 while it sought formal legal advice.
 
That legal guidance, in addition to a shocking lack of official meeting minutes or other written documents and personal recollections from TWC or former 1993 Directors still residing in Hickory Cluster or nearby, led to the discovery that HCA could not confirm formal HCA Member approval of the 1993 Amendments or their registration as required with the State Corporation Commission.  In other words, without documented approval and registration, there were no legally-binding 1993 Amendments to the 1964 Articles of Incorporation.

But wait, there's more:  one unelected Director, appointed in August 2020 just before the September/October 2020 election, resigned recently and effectively created a third Director appointment circumventing an election.  This time, however, the Board did the right thing.  Through a mass mailing to all HCA Members ... still not posted on the new HCA website ... they offered everyone the opportunity for Board appointment.  The official self-nomination Statement of Interest form is due to TWC no later than 3:00 p.m. on Wednesday, January 6, 2021.  Currently, Block 1 is represented by two Directors, Block 2 by no Director, and Block 3 by a voting majority of four Directors, out of seven Directors total.  

Wednesday, August 19, 2020

HCA REGULAR MEETING ONLINE @ WED AUG 19

As previously announced, the HCA Board of Directors will hold a virtual monthly Regular Meeting on Wednesday, August 19, 2020 due to the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.  Virginia law requires homeowners' associations to hold physical public meetings and Director votes, but April 22, 2020 emergency legislation temporarily allows association meetings via electronic means without the requirement of at least two directors meeting in person.  HCA Members can attend the meeting online at https://global.gotomeeting.com/join using the GoToMeeting webpage or app.  Or attendees can dial into the meeting via telephone at (312) 757-3119.  Participation requires a 9-digit Access Code available to HCA Members via email request from HCA Secretary Tom Drake at thomasdrake@hickorycluster.org.  Regular Meetings begin at 7:30 p.m.  For more information contact HCA Secretary Drake.

Monday, July 13, 2020

HCA REGULAR MEETING ONLINE @ WED JUL 15

The HCA Board of Directors advised that they will hold a monthly Regular Meeting on July 15, 2020 as a public GoToMeeting event due to continuing coronavirus pandemic emergency concerns.  Virginia law requires homeowners' associations to hold physical public meetings and Director votes, but April 22, 2020 emergency legislation temporarily allows association meetings via electronic means without the requirement of at least two directors meeting in person.  HCA Members can attend the meeting online at https://global.gotomeeting.com/join using the GoToMeeting webpage or app.  Or attendees can dial into the meeting via telephone at (312) 757-3119.  Participation requires a 9-digit Access Code available to HCA Members via email request from HCA Secretary Tom Drake at thomasdrake@hickorycluster.org.  Regular Meetings begin at 7:30 p.m.  For more information contact HCA Secretary Drake.

Monday, June 22, 2020

VANTAGE HILL INFILL PROJECT DRB MTG @ TUE JUN 23

Reston developed Vantage Hill Cluster condominiums in 1967 to provide non-subsidized affordable workforce housing options.  About eight years ago, the Vantage Hill Condominium Unit Owners Association abandoned its dedicated swimming pool common area due to extensive overall deferred maintenance, insufficient reserves funding, high operating costs, and a gradual transition from owner-occupied to rental units.  Vantage Hill currently contains about 35% rental units within 152 units total, while HCA currently has about 12% rentals within 90 total.  VHCUOA 2019 fees ranged from $35-57 monthly, or $420-680 annually, based on shared condo buildings, infrastructure, and common area.  HCA 2019 fees ranged from about $160-240 monthly, or $1920-2880 annually, based on individual townhome units and 2000-24 Block 3 garage project loan $0-80 monthly payments.  VH 2019 condo sales prices ranged from $140,000-250,000 while HC 2019 townhome sales prices ranged from $399,900-$510,000.  An April 2019 Reston Now article provided an early project report.

To build reserves and fund overdue deferred maintenance and improvement projects, a majority of Vantage Hill homeowners recently agreed to sell their unused 2.12 acre swimming pool common area to a local residential developer Craftmark Homes, who proposes to build up to 31 townhomes, and shift 50 parking spaces to other parts of the property, for which the condo association is projected to receive net proceeds of almost $3,500,000.  Vantage Hill and Craftmark will provide an informational presentation to the Full DRB at its 7:00 p.m. monthly virtual meeting tomorrow, and affected parties may voice their concerns, for which RA made the meeting packet publicly available this morning.   Craftmark mailed required meeting notification letters dated June 2 to 21 HCA and other affected parties directly adjoining Vantage Hill.  In response, neighbors submitted to RA at least 17 individual affected party statements of concerns about building-out dedicated cluster common area to generate revenue, increased building density, reduced open space, street setbacks, traffic, noise, safety, tree removal, storm drainage, animal impacts, and more.

For more June 23 Vantage Hill project application package information, see the following links:
  Developer DRB Application, Attachments
  Vantage Hill Condo Assn. Letter to Owners
  Developer Letter to Affected Parties, Map, List
  Affected Parties Statements of Concern
  Developer Site Plans Proposed
  Developer + Vantage Hill Slide Presentation

To attend the June 23 FDRB virtual Zoom meeting, see the Affected Parties Letter link above and/or the following online access summary:
  Meeting Agenda
  Website:  https://www.zoom.com
  Meeting ID:  956 8866 0759
  Password:  934817

Sunday, June 14, 2020

HCA REGULAR MEETING ONLINE @ WED JUN 17

The HCA Board of Directors advised that they will hold a monthly Regular Meeting on June 17, 2020 as a public GoToMeeting due to continuing coronavirus pandemic emergency concerns.  Virginia law requires homeowners' associations to hold physical public meetings and Director votes, but April 22, 2020 emergency legislation temporarily allows association meetings via electronic means without the requirement of at least two directors meeting in person.  HCA Members can attend the meeting online at https://global.gotomeeting.com/join using the GoToMeeting webpage or app.  Or attendees can dial into the meeting via telephone at (312) 757-3119 or toll free at (866) 899-4679.  Participation requires a 9-digit security Access Code available to HCA Members via email request prior to the meeting from HCA Secretary Tom Drake at thomasdrake@hickorycluster.org.  HCA Regular Meetings begin at 7:30 p.m.  For more information contact HCA Secretary Drake.

Sunday, May 17, 2020

HCA REGULAR MEETING ONLINE @ WED MAY 20

The HCA Board of Directors advised yesterday that they will hold a monthly Regular Meeting on May 20, 2020 as a public GoToMeeting due to continuing coronavirus pandemic emergency orders.  Virginia law requires homeowners' associations to hold physical public meetings and Director votes, but April 22, 2020 emergency legislation temporarily allows association meetings via electronic means without the requirement of at least two directors meeting in person.  However, Code of Virginia Chapter 18 Section 55.1-1815, Paragraph G still requires associations to provide members with at least 14 days annual or regular meeting advance notice.  HCA Members can attend the meeting from a computer, tablet, or smartphone via https://global.gotomeeting.com/join after downloading, installing, and running the GoToMeeting application.  Or attendees can dial into the meeting via telephone at (312) 757-3119 or toll free at (866) 899-4679.  Participation requires a 9-digit meeting security Access Code available to HCA Members via email request prior to the meeting from HCA Secretary Tom Drake at thomasdrake@hickorycluster.org.  HCA Regular Meetings normally begin at 7:30 p.m.  For more information contact HCA Secretary Drake.

UPDATE ... May 20:  TWC provided additional information posted at right via snailmail notice postmarked Monday, May 18 and received today, Wednesday, May 20.  Try printing the page if the screen image lacks readable resolution.  However, HCA Secretary Tom Drake confirmed this evening via email that the information he provided on May 16 for the website posting above, not the snailmail notice at right, is correct for the meeting tonight.  As before, email Tom for the secure access code.

Saturday, April 11, 2020

HCA MEETING LOCATION CHANGE @ WED APR 15

Due to coronavirus pandemic social distancing requirements and lack of available public meeting space, HCA has rescheduled the quarterly HCA Regular Meeting normally held at TWC Association Management offices in Herndon, VA to be held as a virtual public GoToMeeting.  Virginia law requires public Property Owners Association meetings and Director votes.  Members can attend from a computer, tablet, or smartphone via https://global.gotomeeting.com/join after downloading, installing, and running the GoToMeeting application.  Or attendees can dial into the meeting via telephone at (646) 749-3129.  Attendance also requires a 9-digit meeting security Access Code available to HCA Members via email request prior to the meeting from HCA Secretary Tom Drake at thomasdrake@hickorycluster.org.  HCA Regular Meetings normally begin at 7:30 p.m.  For more information contact HCA Secretary Drake.

Wednesday, April 1, 2020

HCA ANNUAL MTG + DIRECTOR ELECTIONS @ SAT MAY 23

Pending coronavirus pandemic public health orders to the contrary and public meeting space availability, the 2020 HCA Annual Meeting of Members is scheduled for 9:00 a.m. to 12:00 noon Saturday, May 23, 2020, in the Rose Gallery at the Reston Community Center Lake Anne.  This is to comply with specific May meeting requirements of HCA 1993 Bylaws Article III, Section 1, unless a Bylaw is amended by a more than 2/3 vote of all Members in compliance with HCA Articles of Incorporation changes enacted by Members in 1993.  TWC typically mails meeting information, Director nomination forms, and Proxy absentee vote forms to all HCA Members in late April or early May.

The following volunteer Director positions are slated for nomination and election in 2020 for which current Directors may be re-elected or new Directors elected:
(1) Two three-year 2020-23 full terms for current Block 1 Director Michael Smith and current Block 2 Director Jeff Ashley who are both completing 2017-20 full terms
(2) One two-year 2020-22 remainder term for former Block 1 Director Matt Collins who sold his Goodman House earlier this year and moved from Reston during his 2019-22 full term
(3) One one-year 2020-21 remainder term for former Block 1 Director Hillary Diebold-Carter who resigned from the Board in 2019 during her 2018-21 full term

HCA encourages interested Members to provide Nomination Form statements of interest and qualifications to TWC as soon as possible, but no later than 1:00 p.m. Friday, May 22, 2020, and to indicate if you would like that information posted on this HCA website.  Or you can choose to be nominated at the Annual Meeting itself.  However, HCA Members not in good standing as of May 22, 2020 are not entitled to vote either in person or by Proxy, or be nominated for a Director position.

Volunteer Directors of this non-profit, non-stock corporation are tasked by the original 1964 HCA Articles of Incorporation with maintaining and improving the Common Areas; enforcing covenants and restrictions; and assessing, collecting, and disbursing funds; all for the benefit of the property and peace, health, comfort, and safety of residents.  Directors typically review budgets, proposals, and contracts; collaborate with other Directors, neighbors, and consultants to make critical decisions; and may provide hands-on project leadership.  Directors must meet at least quarterly, but usually meet monthly.  At whatever level, HCA welcomes your participation.  HCA will also post any updates and the pre-meeting packet on this website.

UPDATES ...
April 22:  As part of 2020 State Budget Bill HB29, the Virginia House and Senate enacted emergency legislation in Part 4: General Provisions, Item 4-0.01 Operating Policies, Paragraph g., allowing Virginia homeowners' associations to meet via electronic means without an otherwise required two-director physical quorum during states of emergency declared by the governor, as is the case now during the coronavirus pandemic, if the association complies with other requirements including member notice, access, comments, and minutes.  This provides associations like HCA with an option to comply with specific bylaws meeting schedule and other requirements, as did RA at its videoconference annual meeting on April 30 instead of its planned April 14 physical meeting date.
April 29:  HCA Directors decided to reschedule the 2020 HCA Annual Meeting from May 23 to September 19, 2020. 
May 1:  HCA advised Members of the Director meeting date change via a mailed written notice and a related Written Consent based on Virginia Nonstock Corporation Act Chapter 10, Section 13.1-865. entitled "Action without meeting of board of directors."

Tuesday, March 17, 2020

HCA REGULAR MEETING CANCELED @ WED MAR 18

HCA advised today that the HCA monthly Regular Meeting will not be held as scheduled tomorrow at the LAVC RCC Lake Anne Rose Gallery.  Effective Monday, March 16, Fairfax County Government closed RCC Lake Anne and RCC Hunters Woods for at least the next two weeks to decrease community spread of the pandemic coronavirus.  Both the County and Commonwealth of Virginia have declared respective emergencies, closing schools and other public facilities, including County ReCenters.  Updates on any future changes will be posted on this website.

Tuesday, December 17, 2019

HCA MEETING LOCATION CHANGE @ WED DEC 18

The HCA Board of Directors advises that the December 18 monthly HCA Regular Meeting will be held at the Reston Museum, in the Lake Anne Village Center at 1639 Washington Plaza North, due to earlier scheduling conflicts at RCC Lake Anne.  Regular Meetings are scheduled to start at 7:30 p.m. and are open to the public.

RESTON HISTORIC BLDG SURVEY MTG @ TUE DEC 17

In 1991, the Virginia Dept. of Historic Resources initiated a Survey and Planning Cost Share Program to assist local governments.  The program also supports the DHR mission to identify cultural resources statewide and record them in the DHR VCRIS digital database.  More than 120 Virginia communities have competed to participate and receive limited matching annual funding, and with DHR have conducted 150-plus projects in every region of the Commonwealth.  As a result, each year the DHR inventory of architectural and archeological resources grows with the addition of more than 4,000 newly recorded properties. 

In 2019, DHR selected Fairfax County to participate in a survey covering all of Reston except within the existing Lake Anne Historic Overlay District as designated by Fairfax County.  DHR thoroughly documented and added Lake Anne Village Center to the Virginia Landmarks Register in 2017, which led to listing in the U.S. National Park Service National Register of Historic Places.  DHR listed Reston overall in 2014.

For the 2019 Reston survey project, DHR will hire expert consultants to photograph, map, and document properties with information about building style, construction date, architectural description, and preliminary evaluation of relative significance.  The sites or buildings can then be nominated to be included in the County Inventory of Historic Sites, the Virginia Landmarks Register, or the National Register of Historic Places.  Although such honorary designations do not ensure a building's survival, Bauhaus Professor and Master Architect Marcel Breuer's 1964 Reston API Building, the only Breuer building in Virginia, was permitted for 2016 demolition primarily because it was not listed within the incomplete and outdated Fairfax County inventory that covered Hunter Mill District sites and buildings through only 1920.  Sadly, the permitted developer replaced the bold modernist Breuer API Building with typical, nondescript, cookie-cutter townhomes.

DHR and Fairfax County will hold a joint public information meeting this evening to kick off the project at RCC Lake Anne at 7:00 p.m.  They will also brief the community on completed survey findings early next year.